With Us
Our Offices
Bridgehampton Office 631.537.3200
East Hampton Office 631.324.8080
East Hampton Annex 631.324.8080
Greenport Office 631.477.5990
Mattituck Office 631.298.0600
Montauk Office 631.668.0500
Southampton Office 631.283.5800
Westhampton Office 631.288.3030
Get In Touch

    Main Content

    St Marys, Shelter Island

    SHELTER ISLAND COMPOUND WITH ABILITY TO SUBDIVIDE Welcome to a haven of natural beauty with limitless opportunities. This meticulously crafted Shelter Island 8.45acre estate property is currently configured with 3 substantial structures: a 3Bed/4Bath primary residence, a 2-car carriage house with loft apartment and a 3 stall horse barn with tack room and loft space. This is a rare opportunity to live your equestrian dreams OR IF YOU'RE NOT A HORSE ENTHUSIAST, this C-Zone property can be reimagined as your own sprawling compound with commercial/work options or the property can be subdivided into separate parcels. The pastures, paddocks and cedar grove make this a true gem for horse enthusiasts, a family compound with multiple dwelling options or as gym/yoga, art studio or light commercial/work spaces. The centerpiece of this remarkable estate is the main residence, a 3225 square foot country home boasting 3bedrooms and 4 bathrooms. All bedrooms are ensuite and the home also boast formal dining room, entry way, main floor laundry and ample size living/family room. Also on the first floor, the primary suite is equipped with a beautiful sunroom with radiant heat floors. large dressing room, and extra-large ensuite bathroom with soaking tub. The second floor has two ensuite bedrooms and a bonus family/ media room as optional 4th bedroom with high ceilings. The finished expansive lower level with full bath is walk out to the rolling property. Above the two-car garage there is loft apartment space with kitchen and full bathroom. This expansive space also boasts high ceilings and a balcony overlooking the 18x 44 gunite pool with waterfall. In addition, the property has a functional horse barn with 3 stalls tack room and loft space OR reimagine to suit your needs. As a horse farm this expansive Shelter Island property represents a rare opportunity to own a world-class equestrian estate in one of the most beautiful and sought-after locations in the region. Whether you are a seasoned equestrian or simply seeking a serene escape, this property features the perfect blend of luxury, natural beauty, and equestrian excellence. Don't miss your chance to make this dream equestrian retreat your own.


    44 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS courtesy of Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons. Information Copyright 2021, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved.

    WEB # ONE3508407
    Get In Touch
    Greenport Office 120 Front Street
    Greenport, NY 11944
    View Office
    Share this Listing
    Share Listing
    St Marys, Shelter Island

      Required fields are marked *

      Share via link